Are you solving the wrong problem?

How to ask the right questions to uncover the real issue at the core of a project.

09/18/2012


“We need quatre binaries on this loop.” At this point, I’d heard this statement on what seemed like every loop we were discussing. I was in a meeting in Paris to define the DCS requirements of a paper machine project with the engineering company.

Pour quoi?” I asked. Okay, I don’t really speak French, but I’d picked up a couple of things since arriving in France, and every time the engineer said that he had to have four discrete outputs associated with a control loop, it meant that I had to use a more expensive piece of hardware. So I finally asked the right question, “Why?” The answer stunned me. The only DCS he knew required the user to hardwire outputs back to inputs to generate an alarm! I explained to him that our system didn’t work that way, and so we started over in defining the system. If I’d never asked why, I’d have quoted a very over priced and overly capable system for a simple application and lost the project.

It was early in my career and this incident taught me a lot about getting to the real drivers of what seems to be a rather straightforward issue. As an engineer, I had been trained to take the data I was given, process it through some rather black-and-white filters and produce an answer. Did I have a controller with four discrete outputs? Yes. Did the customer ask for four discrete outputs? Yes. So that’s the controller he needed, n’est-ce pas? No. What he needed was a way to notify the operator of a problem in the system. What I needed was to understand what problem he was trying to solve.

Asking why is easy for kids, but can be very uncomfortable for adults. We take it as a challenge or even an affront to our intelligence, but asked the right way, it can save us from going down the wrong path. Saying “Help me understand…” is often the most revealing question you can ask. As Yogi Berra (supposedly) said, “If you don’t know where you’re going, you’ll probably end up some place else.”

This post was written by Bruce Brandt. Bruce is the DeltaV technology leader at MAVERICK Technologies, a leading system integrator providing industrial automation, operational support and control systems engineering services in the manufacturing and process industries. MAVERICK delivers expertise and consulting in a wide variety of areas including industrial automation controls, distributed control systems, manufacturing execution systems, operational strategy, and business process optimization. The company provides a full range of automation and controls services – ranging from PID controller tuning and HMI programming to serving as a main automation contractor. Additionally MAVERICK offers industrial and technical staffing services, placing on-site automation, instrumentation and controls engineers.



No comments
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by...
The System Integrator Giants program lists the top 100 system integrators among companies listed in CFE Media's Global System Integrator Database.
The Engineering Leaders Under 40 program identifies and gives recognition to young engineers who...
This eGuide illustrates solutions, applications and benefits of machine vision systems.
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
Salary and career survey: Benchmarks and advice; Designing controls; Remote data collection, historians; Control valve advances; Hannover Messe; Control Engineering International
System integration: Best practices and technologies to help; Virtualization virtues; Cyber security advice; Motor system efficiency, savings; Product exclusives; Road to Hannover
Collaborative robotics: How to improve safety, return on investment; Industrial Internet of Things, Industrie 4.0: World views; High-performance HMI, Information Integration: OPC and OMG
This article collection contains several articles on the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) and how it is transforming manufacturing.
PLCs, robots, and the quest for a single controller; how OEE is key to automation solutions.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

Getting to the bottom of subsea repairs: Older pipelines need more attention, and operators need a repair strategy; OTC preview; Offshore production difficult - and crucial
Digital oilfields: Integrated HMI/SCADA systems enable smarter data acquisition; Real-world impact of simulation; Electric actuator technology prospers in production fields
Special report: U.S. natural gas; LNG transport technologies evolve to meet market demand; Understanding new methane regulations; Predictive maintenance for gas pipeline compressors
click me