Feedback: Criteria for PLC vs. DCS evaluation

11/17/2006


I read your article about the Eli Lilly engineer’s (Mike Alward) comparison of PLC versus DCS. [ Control Engineering Weekly News email newsletter, Oct. 31, 2006; “ Automation Fair: Pharma engineer rates PLC system over DCS .”]

What were the 19 criteria used to compare? This is so I can understand the viewpoint of giving a 77-73 lead to the PLC. We do run into the comparison once in awhile, and, yes, it [the DCS advantage] does seem to disappear, as PLC functionality gets closer to the DCS. Thank you.
—James Pfeifer, R.E.T., F.S.E, senior control systems specialist, IMV Projects , Calgary, Alberta, Canada

PLC vs. DCS criteria are…
I appreciate your feedback on the PLC versus DCS debate. For those just picking up the discussion, the article, linked above, compares a control system based on programmable logic controllers and distributed control systems. While I included some criteria provided by Mike Alward, lead system architect at Eli Lilly (Indianapolis, IN), I should have figured readers would want them all.

Here are the 19 criteria Alward mentioned:

  1. Control execution speed

  2. Control templates provided

  3. Control templates, ability to create

  4. Control, advanced

  5. Control, analog

  6. Control, machine

  7. Cost for implemented system

  8. Global tag, parameter accessibility

  9. HMI development / integration

  10. Integrated hardware solution

  11. Integrated software solution

  12. Integration of non-vendor provided components and applications

  13. OEM equipment, ease of integration with

  14. Programming language capabilities

  15. Recipe functionality

  16. Redundancy, fault tolerance

  17. Scalability

  18. Security, logical

  19. System integrators, availability of effective

For more Control Engineering research and trends on PLCs and on process control, read:

Also, type the words control systems in the search box atop any page at www.controleng.com for other related reading.

—Mark T. Hoske , Control Engineering editor in chief





No comments
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by...
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners.
The Engineering Leaders Under 40 program identifies and gives recognition to young engineers who...
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
Learn how to create value with re-use; gain productivity with lean automation and connectivity, and optimize panel design and construction.
Go deep: Automation tackles offshore oil challenges; Ethernet advice; Wireless robotics; Product exclusives; Digital edition exclusives
Lost in the gray scale? How to get effective HMIs; Best practices: Integrate old and new wireless systems; Smart software, networks; Service provider certifications
Fixing PID: Part 2: Tweaking controller strategy; Machine safety networks; Salary survey and career advice; Smart I/O architecture; Product exclusives
The Ask Control Engineering blog covers all aspects of automation, including motors, drives, sensors, motion control, machine control, and embedded systems.
Look at the basics of industrial wireless technologies, wireless concepts, wireless standards, and wireless best practices with Daniel E. Capano of Diversified Technical Services Inc.
Join this ongoing discussion of machine guarding topics, including solutions assessments, regulatory compliance, gap analysis...
This is a blog from the trenches – written by engineers who are implementing and upgrading control systems every day across every industry.
IMS Research, recently acquired by IHS Inc., is a leading independent supplier of market research and consultancy to the global electronics industry.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

Case Study Database

Case Study Database

Get more exposure for your case study by uploading it to the Control Engineering case study database, where end-users can identify relevant solutions and explore what the experts are doing to effectively implement a variety of technology and productivity related projects.

These case studies provide examples of how knowledgeable solution providers have used technology, processes and people to create effective and successful implementations in real-world situations. Case studies can be completed by filling out a simple online form where you can outline the project title, abstract, and full story in 1500 words or less; upload photos, videos and a logo.

Click here to visit the Case Study Database and upload your case study.