So do you need a micro PLC or a PAC (programmable automation controller)? What's the difference, and, if you do want a programmable logic controller, what designates a "micro PLC," and do traditional monikers still apply? It may be that the functionality a controller brings from automation design through implementation, use, repair, and upgrades is more important than the type of controller.
This article contains Online Extras
So do you need a micro PLC or a PAC (programmable automation controller)? What's the difference, and, if you do want a programmable logic controller, what designates a 'micro PLC,' and do traditional monikers still apply?
It may be that the functionality a controller brings from automation design through implementation, use, repair, and upgrades is more important than the type of controller. As for size, all bets are off on traditional measures such as input/output (I/O) count; just get the functions needed for the application, perhaps with a bit more for any possible expansion.
In general PACs are PLC-like in form factor and function with industrially hardened PC-based logic and capabilities, more open, with easier, built-in communications, and often with more programming flexibility than PLCs.
Even so, PLCs have continued to advance in ease of use, communications, and other functionality. Mid-year 2004, ARC Advisory Group noted, 'PLCs have now become so much of a commodity that suppliers of PLCs often do not know the end use of the nano- and micro-PLCs that they sell through distributors.' Control Engineering 's November 2004 PLC research (to be updated in the December issue) noted, 'Micro and medium are the most widely installed types of PLCs.'
Small-sized PLCs pack in features unheard of a few years ago, suggests Sydney Brooks, senior technical support specialist, Panasonic Electric Works Corp. of America (formerly Aromat, NAiS). The new compact FP-X brick-style PLC, for instance, has I/O cassettes that stack atop the PLC; it has eight built in high-speed counters, for encoders, proximity or photoelectric sensors, compared to competitors that have two, on average, Brooks said.
As with other PLCs, 'Most micro PLCs have adopted the IEC 61131-3 programming standard, which defines a standard instruction set, datatypes, and programming environment,' explains Mark DeCramer, Wago product manager, advanced electronics. Often-covered advantages include reusable code, processor-independent programming, code portability across PLC brands, and, DeCramer suggests, a faster learning curve. 'If you're not using a micro PLC supported by IEC 61131-3 programming, the money you're saving on your micro PLC hardware is being spent elsewhere on excessive engineering and training costs.'
PAC, PLC, or both?
The application should help determine if a PLC or PAC (or both) should be used, suggests Gricha Raether, data acquisition product manager, National Instruments.
'Today's control processes rely on myriad signals and data, ranging from analog and digital I/O devices to high-resolution, high-speed cameras, and multi-axis motion controllers,' Raether says. 'Applications like high-speed production, real-time machine condition monitoring, high-precision control, and complex process control require high-speed data acquisition, advanced analysis, and processing algorithms to be executed deterministically.'
High-end PLCs, he admits, can satisfy some of these requirements, but 'engineers need computational resources, such as floating-point processors and substantial memory, to handle these signals efficiently. PACs integrate this off-the-shelf hardware with a real-time operating system to provide a cost-efficient platform for control engineers.' (See online sidebar for more on this point.) NI products include PACs and logic boards, not PLCs.
When selecting a smaller PLC versus a larger PAC, says Tim Roberts, staff product specialist and team leader, low end control products, Schneider Electric, 'consider the size and breadth of the application, and determine if the smaller PLC like a 'nano PLC' is suitable. A nano PLC can be an option for complex machine applications while a PAC is usually the preferable option for complex processes.' Roberts says, 'If a smaller PLC is suitable for the application, then determine if the PLC has adequate I/O count (discrete and analog), PID loops, adequate memory, communications capabilities, and processing speed that is fast enough. Physical dimensions should be a consideration as well if space is an issue.' Applications show advantages and adaptability of today's small controllers.
North Eastern Ohio Co., an OEM of automated painting machines, required near real-time coordination of multi axis motion with digital and analog outputs. The prior setup included a motion card and I/O card(s) installed in a Real Time Unix-based industrial PC. Code resided in the PC and on the motion card.
The upgrade needed to maintain the existing motion platform because of an installed base, and it added I/O-based logic that could independently operate non-robotic functions, like paint filling. The new application combined an Ethernet-based stand-alone motion controller, Microsoft Windows PC, and Wago Ethernet Programmable Field Bus Coupler. Artomation By Digital Coating Devices Inc. supplied and integrated the controller/HMI; Chuck Greene, vice president, product development, outlined benefits in this application:
Motion controller was same manufacturer so motion software didn't change.
Microsoft Windows PC cut the cost of PC by more than 50%.
Wago I/O connections provided direct communication to motion using Modbus protocol. Cost of I/O modules fell 10-20% for standard equipment and as much as 40% on machines that require expanded I/O connections, which can be added at any voltage in the field, using a power feed module. Communications to multiple field devices included RS-485.
'We were able to write a configuration utility that allows us to add I/O points without re-writing software. Simply configure and go,' Greene notes. Wago 842 PFC (programmable field controller) uses IEC 61131-3 standard programming and functions on its own. 'Motion communicates via Modbus to notify I/O devices which process to run. I/O runs process independently of motion and PC, allowing the operation to load paint, test spray gun setup, etc.' For applications that don't require motion, the Wago controller functions on its own; using a specialty module it reads an encoder on the conveyor and triggers the correct guns on or off as parts move by.
Standing water is not something that you want to see or smell while waiting for your train (or working in an industrial environment). Better to ensure any runoff 'takes the express' to an appropriate location. Toronto Transportation Co. (TTC) has installed ITT Flygt's Logimac PLC-based pumping systems at all of its stations, after seeking to standardize controllers. ITT Flygt Canada sought reliable, cost-effective powerful control, with flexible communications, and strong service and support.
Designed for use with duplex, triplex, and quadruplex pumping stations, a Logimac system includes a PLC running a standard industry-specific program that ITT Flygt Canada developed for identification of faulty equipment and safe and reliable operation of the pumping station, and an operator interface. The system monitors and controls overheating of the pump motor stator and ball bearings, liquid infiltration inside the pump motor stator and pump junction box, and detection of faulty level regulators. It also monitors inputs, including switches or pressure sensors that measure incoming flow volume. If wastewater surpasses a pre-determined level, the PLC sends a command to one or more pumps to begin pumping to a treatment plant.
'The Logimac system is powerful enough to calculate pumped volume based on incoming flow,' says Luc-Rejean Lepine, product manager, ITT Flygt Canada. 'By automatically bringing more pumps into operation when needed, the system prevents overflow of untreated wastewater to the rivers, enabling better wastewater treatment.' Lepine says GE Fanuc's micro PLCs benefit ITT Flygt Canada and its customers. Currently used VersaMax Micro PLC is expandable up to 84 I/O points and used with variable-frequency drives and soft starters. 'These controllers are powerful, reliable, and cost-effective,' Lepine says. 'They are also easily customizable, which is important to us and our customers.' Industry-standard, easy-to-use programming also enables ITT Flygt Canada to commission pumping stations quickly.
Vipa GmbH Speed 7 line of PLCs is touted as the world’s fastest hard PLC. The CPU 315SBasic, programmable with Step7 software from Siemens, is said to take 100k instructions in 2 ms, 128k to 1Mbyte memory, an integrated Ethernet interface, and an attractive price/performance ratio. It has PC compatible via memory configuration card with a FAT16 file system. Standard communications are MP2I, Profibus DP-Master, and Ethernet. Up to 32 Vipa System 300-V modules and 16 Speed modules are connectable in one line. www.speed7.com
Do you need a PLC or PAC?
Given PACs’ advanced capabilities, they are not meant to replace PLCs but rather to complement them in existing applications, says Gricha Raether, data acquisition product manager, National Instruments. Optimizing a specific part of an existing production line or process with a PAC is easy due to their open architecture.
“For instance,” Raether says, “you can add real-time process thermal analysis by performing the analysis and high-speed control on a PAC and updating the rest of the system through standard Ethernet or shared registers in commercial gateways. With a PAC, you also can perform high-speed vibration monitoring that detects extraneous conditions, performs machine analysis and updates a signal on the overall system. This ability could impact the long-term capacity of your plant.” Doing the same thing with a PLC requires engineers know traditional ladder-logic programming, have a detailed understanding of the machines that require optimization, and possess knowledge in the manipulation of advanced types of I/O devices and processing algorithms, Raether contends.
“With National Instruments LabView, programming PACs is simplified. PACs, designed to perform computationally intensive operations, are available in several models depending on the application. Some PACs dedicate all of their processing power to one function, such as machine vision; however, other PACs have gigahertz processors and are powerful enough to perform multiple tasks, including motion, vision, and high-speed measurements. Using these PACs, you can update hundreds of PID loops within microseconds or create trajectories for multi-axial motion control systems at millimeter precision.”
More about small-controller applications
Here’s additional information about several applications described in the main article.
Automated painting: Requirements for new painting system, as described by Artomation:
1) Microsoft Windows-based PC for operator interface (cost effective and readily available);
2) Continue using existing motion platform due to installed base;
3) Stand-alone I/O platform (I/O card in PC was risky when reading external inputs);
4) Easily expandable I/O points. An I/O card in PC was seen to limit expandability. Additional cards were expensive and required software changes. Communication through RS-485 required use of serial port and RS-485 converter.
5) I/O device needed to function on its own for non-motion-related functions (such as automatically loading paint).
6) For applications not requiring motion, stationary spray guns are positioned to spray parts moving by on a conveyor. “There is no motion involved, so the spray guns need to trigger on only when a part is present at a spray gun,” says Chuck Greene, vice president, product development, Artomation by Digital Coating Devices Inc. He adds, “The power of the programmable controller combined with the low cost fit well with both sections of our business.”
Better door building: Fred Braid says he was born with “sawdust running through my veins.” Since the 1930s, his family has been involved in the U.S. and international door industry. Throughout the 1960s and 1970s, Braid and his brother Ken learned the ins and outs of building door units with pneumatic controlled production equipment, much of it designed by their father. In 1981, Braid founded Full House Co., a family-owned business located in Melbourne, FL. The company designs, manufactures, rebuilds, and services machinery used to manufacture prehung door units, which consist of both the doors and the frames on which they are hung.
Siemens PLCs and touch screen technology ensured consistency in each door unit produced, “It is much easier for our customers to make changes because of the touch panel, especially for special jobs,” Braid says. “Many of the door shops today are doing more 8-foot doors in various sizes and various frames. Now, all they have to do is touch the screen to change hinge locations, lock bore height, and other variations. In the past, changes were time-consuming mechanical procedures. Now, anybody can do it.”
Sean Morgan, Full House development engineer, praised the network Siemens recommended for the application. “The AS-interface requires minimal electrical knowledge, and that is a feature we like to promote to our customers. Once you understand the basics of the AS-interface system, you cannot make wiring mistakes.” In addition, Carl Oberg, Full House production manager, says the AS-interface bus system plays a big role in simplifying and making speeding changes to the ma-chine. In the past, an entirely new wiring system would have to be installed to accommodate add-on features. When using the AS-interface bus system, no additional wiring is required to make changes. “All customers have to do is clip on to the AS-interface bus,” Oberg says. “If we offer a new option, it is very easy to meet customers’ needs because no additional wiring is required.”
Further, Oberg says Full House can now instantly change hinge and lock locations. In the past, he says, with pneumatic machines, it was expensive to make a mechanical change to a machine. “It now takes seconds compared to one hour to make changes. The Marquise Diamond is doing a lot more than any of the machines currently out there, especially with special orders. Specials are usually very labor intensive. Now a special can run through the Marquise with no problem.” Today, Full House offers 25 door manufacturing machines. Braid plans to begin transitioning to Siemens PLCs and touchscreen technology on all the company’s units in the near future. “By standardizing on one platform for all our machines, it is much easier for us to maintain them in the field and over the Internet, especially for overseas machines,” Braid says. “Our machines are all similar but we offer up to 10 different options. The nice thing about the Siemens S7-200 PLC platform is a customer can start with a couple of options and add others later. As a result, the machine never becomes obsolete. We couldn’t offer that with a pneumatic system.”
Full House Co. designed the Marquise Diamond door and jamb machine with PLC instead of pneumatic controls, incorporating the most-requested customer features.
Removing wastewater: ITT Flygt Canada has standardized on GE Fanuc’s micro PLCs as its pump controllers of choice. ITT Flygt is one of the world’s leading suppliers of submersible pumps to the pulp and paper, mining, and construction industries as well as municipalities. The company sells both standalone pumps and pump monitors and controls. When the monitoring and controls part of the business started growing rapidly several years ago, ITT Flygt Canada started looking for a controller—and a supplier—it could count on. Its distributor, Gescan, a Quebec-based division of Sonepar Distribution, showed ITT Flygt GE Fanuc’s micro PLC—and ITT Flygt was impressed. “GE Fanuc’s micro PLCs have the combination of power and affordability that we need for our Logimac systems,” says LucRejean Lepine, product manager, ITT Flygt Canada. Prior GE Fanuc PLCs used included Series 90, Series 90-30 to, currently, the VersaMax Micro. And, just as ITT Flygt Canada is committed to providing customers with outstanding support, it has been very happy with GE Fanuc service. “We have received an excellent level of support from GE Fanuc,” Lepine says. Another attractive feature of VersaMax PLCs, says Lepine, is support of ModBus protocol, even if customers don’t currently require open communications. Based on positive experiences with GE Fanuc and its micro PLCs, ITT Flygt Canada is considering using GE Fanuc operator interfaces on its Logimac systems.
Opto 22 is among companies that have blurred the line between PLC and I/O systems by including intelligence and communications on I/O modules. Here’s a link to a recent product introduction, exclusive in Control Engineering in June:
Looking ahead, please watch www.controleng.com/archives for a December 2005 article on high-end PC-based control and “Product Research” on PLCs.
Old measures for PLCs fall away with new technologies
I/O counts were among traditional measures for PLC sizes cited in the past.
Nano: Less than 15 I/O points;
Micro: 16-128 I/O points;
Medium: 129-511 I/O points, and
Large: 512 and more I/O points.
Nano: 0-64 I/O points;
Micro: 65-128 I/O points;
Medium: 129-256 I/O points; and
Large: 256 or more I/O points.
However, today's 'smallest' PLCs often exceed I/O capabilities of yesterday's 'large' PLCs, so it's best to look for needed functionality rather than I/O-based size, experts say.
GE Fanuc VersaMax Micro Nano PLC fits in operational environments where panel space is limited but high volume production and processor speeds are required. With all-in-one construction, this compact PLC provides up to 64 I/O points (expandable to 176), fast cycle times, a robust instruction set, and extensive memory to multiply programming options. Modular design is said to allow flexibility and easy installation.
Panasonic Electric Works Corp. of America offers FP-X, with a set of features and functions said to rival all competitors. With processor speeds of 0.32pansions available for the FP0 series PLC.
Allen-Bradley MicroLogix 1100 controller from Rockwell Automation offers a cost-effective, low-end controller with the flexibility of online editing. List priced at $550, the new controller helps users modify programs, including PID (proportional integral differential) loops, while online. Embedded EtherNet/IP communications port shares data across a production facility and eliminates network wiring. An embedded Ethernet Web server gives users remote access to control information. Applications include distributed control across an Ethernet network, such as in material handling or packaging applications, and supervisory control and data acquisition, with the controller as a remote terminal unit. Built-in, multipurpose text LCD screen may eliminate need for a separate operator interface in many applications.
Telemecanique Twido nanoPLC from Schneider Electric has capabilities that many larger PLCs do, but in a smaller package. With multiple communication capabilities, it is said to be a 'very powerful product for its size,' with 'the fastest cycle times per instruction logic.'
EXCLUSIVE PLC control: Full House Co. cuts door/jamb machine downtime, boosts production
Fred Braid of Full House Co. says that not much has changed in the door machinery industry since his father pioneered pre-hung doors. In fact, machines controlled by relays, valves, and compressed air are the standard for Braid's customers and competitors alike.
In 2004, however, Braid broke nearly 70 years of pneumatic-control tradition with the Marquise Diamond, Full House's first PLC-controlled, servo-driven door-and-jamb machine. Braid's goal was to build a machine that would carry on the company's mission: designing equipment that helps door companies increase profits by streamlining production and reducing labor costs. Braid and the Full House engineering team worked with Siemens Energy & Automation through the transition. Goals included increased precision, improved product quality, and flexibility to quickly and easily change setup parameters for door and jamb products.
'What we wanted to accomplish with the new machine would have been very complicated with traditional pneumatic logic,' Braid says.
Full House chose Siemens Simatic S7-200 PLC programmed with MicroWin software to keep the company ahead of the competition that continued to offer only pneumatic control machines. Marquise Diamond Door & Jamb Machine's high production rate (60 doors per hour) offers door manufacturers high levels of quality and versatility when machining wooden and fiberglass doors up to 8-ft high and 4-ft wide. Setup can be changed in seconds with a Siemens Simatic TP-270, a 10-in., touchscreen HMI programmed with Siemens ProTool Pro software, compared to the normal one-hour changeover time on pneumatic models. Sean Morgan, Full House development engineer, praised the flexibility of being able to reprogram and change-out parts, technical support, and service. S7-200 PLC controls all operations of the Marquise Diamond via an AS-interface, a multi-vendor bus system that transfers process- and machine-level digital and analog signals. Data and supply voltage are transmitted over a two-wire cable. It eliminates more costly parallel wiring, offers flexibility for add-on features, and has plug-and-play functionality, Morgan says, helping installers with mechanical backgrounds. Because of the bus system, features can be added without wiring changes.
PLCs reduce maintenance, simplify operation, and decrease service calls and downtime compared to Full House pneumatic machines. Braid says, 'No longer are air quality issues, incorrect air pressures, and water in the system causing problems. Also, we can perform diagnostics and control the machine over the Internet,' obviously better than sending a service technician overseas.
'The Marquise Diamond takes a door slab and machines it for the hinges and bores it for the lock,' says Carl Oberg, Full House production manager. 'If the hinge locations are off or the door lock is off, poor quality results. Consistency is key. If a problem does arise, it is corrected much faster with the PLC than with pneumatic control.'
Braid says the HMI reduces labor and material costs by decreasing time for changes or to correct problems. Hinge and lock changes take seconds rather than the hour for pneumatic machines. Special orders, Oberg added, often 'required running a door through a machine twice. That could take up to seven minutes.' It's now less than one.
|Search the online Automation Integrator Guide|
Case Study Database
Get more exposure for your case study by uploading it to the Control Engineering case study database, where end-users can identify relevant solutions and explore what the experts are doing to effectively implement a variety of technology and productivity related projects.
These case studies provide examples of how knowledgeable solution providers have used technology, processes and people to create effective and successful implementations in real-world situations. Case studies can be completed by filling out a simple online form where you can outline the project title, abstract, and full story in 1500 words or less; upload photos, videos and a logo.
Click here to visit the Case Study Database and upload your case study.