Reviewed resource: Profibus PA and Foundation Fieldbus—a cost comparison

02/06/2008


We recently received a new whitepaper from the Profibus Trade Organization (PTO) written by James Powell, a Siemens engineer, on the topic of fieldbus costs. The conclusion of the paper is that Profibus is less expensive than Foundation Fieldbus . You can take that claim as you will, but the larger issues of how the two platforms differ make for a more interesting discussion and a reason to read the whitepaper. Download the paper at the Control Engineering resource center.

This functionality has been a topic of much thought recently because of an article on fieldbus applications coming in the March issue of Control Engineering . In doing that research, I have heard users discuss the pros and cons of the two main instrumentation fieldbus protocols: Foundation Fieldbus (FF) and Profibus PA. So far, price comparisons have not been an issue, but differences of functionality and availability of devices have.

While the two platforms have many similarities, there are two key functional differences:

FF supports control in the field (defined as devices that can run their own control loops) which Profibus doesn’t. FF achieves this by placing control functionality in individual devices. Profibus users regulate loops from the DCS through the network.

Profibus is more adaptable to supporting hybrid networks (defined as networks that can operate drives and other discrete equipment, in addition to instrumentation and valves, using combined PA and DP) which FF doesn’t do, or at least doesn’t do well enough to be practical. Plants that use FF for instrumentation and valves typically deploy Profibus DP, DeviceNet, or something else for other types of equipment. While this approach works and is commonly used, a plant has to support multiple platforms from different vendors.

One user that I interviewed at a paper mill said his company had researched the topic extensively and decided to use Foundation Fieldbus for instrumentation to take advantage of the control capability. He went on to say that they also run Profibus DP as a second system to support drives, which is one of the points made in the whitepaper. Those FF-enabled instruments require additional circuitry in the device to support those control capabilities (whether you use them or not), which accounts for higher costs per device.

Cost, in general, is not one of the major concerns when deciding whether to use fieldbus networking or not, or which platform. The ultimate value of more sophisticated architectures over traditional hard-wiring comes from shortened commissioning times, simpler troubleshooting techniques, instrumentation diagnostics, and more effective maintenance to name a few. In some cases there are actual savings on wiring, but this is usually a relatively minor issue. The benefit of the whitepaper is that it will help you consider some of these functional issues. That in itself has value.

—Peter Welander, process industries editor, PWelander@cfemedia.com ,
Process & Advanced Control Monthly
Register here and scroll down to select your choice of free eNewsletters.





No comments
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by...
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners.
Control Engineering Leaders Under 40 identifies and gives recognition to young engineers who...
Learn more about methods used to ensure that the integration between the safety system and the process control...
Adding industrial toughness and reliability to Ethernet eGuide
Technological advances like multiple-in-multiple-out (MIMO) transmitting and receiving
Virtualization advice: 4 ways splitting servers can help manufacturing; Efficient motion controls; Fill the brain drain; Learn from the HART Plant of the Year
Two sides to process safety: Combining human and technical factors in your program; Preparing HMI graphics for migrations; Mechatronics and safety; Engineers' Choice Awards
Detecting security breaches: Forensic invenstigations depend on knowing your networks inside and out; Wireless workers; Opening robotic control; Product exclusive: Robust encoders
The Ask Control Engineering blog covers all aspects of automation, including motors, drives, sensors, motion control, machine control, and embedded systems.
Join this ongoing discussion of machine guarding topics, including solutions assessments, regulatory compliance, gap analysis...
News and comments from Control Engineering process industries editor, Peter Welander.
IMS Research, recently acquired by IHS Inc., is a leading independent supplier of market research and consultancy to the global electronics industry.
This is a blog from the trenches – written by engineers who are implementing and upgrading control systems every day across every industry.
Anthony Baker is a fictitious aggregation of experts from Callisto Integration, providing manufacturing consulting and systems integration.
Integrator Guide

Integrator Guide

Search the online Automation Integrator Guide
 

Create New Listing

Visit the System Integrators page to view past winners of Control Engineering's System Integrator of the Year Award and learn how to enter the competition. You will also find more information on system integrators and Control System Integrators Association.

Case Study Database

Case Study Database

Get more exposure for your case study by uploading it to the Control Engineering case study database, where end-users can identify relevant solutions and explore what the experts are doing to effectively implement a variety of technology and productivity related projects.

These case studies provide examples of how knowledgeable solution providers have used technology, processes and people to create effective and successful implementations in real-world situations. Case studies can be completed by filling out a simple online form where you can outline the project title, abstract, and full story in 1500 words or less; upload photos, videos and a logo.

Click here to visit the Case Study Database and upload your case study.