Temperature diagnostics help prevent unplanned shutdowns

Your instrumentation may be trying to warn you of a developing problem. Usually this warning will give you time to prevent a production interruption, if you’re paying attention.

03/07/2014


In most industrial process plants, unit operations have become increasingly complex. That combined with the ever-increasing demands on operations and maintenance personnel for their time, make it very difficult for them to proactively monitor the health and performance of all measurement and control instrumentation. As a result, many problems go unnoticed until they cause production or quality issues, or even worse, an unscheduled shutdown.

In today's modern process plants, production and quality systems put new and much tighter requirements on the accuracy and performance of process instruments and control. Proactive identification of performance issues before production is impacted has become the rule and not the exception in many facilities. As a result, many plants have turned to diagnostics as a way to identify issues before they become problems. For example, the diagnostic features designed into temperature transmitters monitor the process and provide diagnostic information. As a result, issues are identified before they cause process upsets, dangerous conditions, or measurement failure.

Temperature transmitters have an enormous capability to run full-time diagnostics. Many offer a vast array of options and features to assure that an accurate and stable measurement is reported to the control system. Many of these alerts can prioritize maintenance scheduling for more efficient use of available maintenance resources.

Understanding temperature transmitters and diagnostics

While all smart temperature transmitters have diagnostics, some are considerably more extensive than others. There are normally internal diagnostics that monitor transmitter functionality and output validity. Also, there is a wide range of external diagnostic functions that monitor the measurement signal for drift, degradation, measurement validity, and broken or damaged leads. Of all transmitters that are available, those that use HART, Foundation fieldbus, or Profibus protocols offer a high level of sophistication.

Transmitters initiate either alerts or alarms based upon these diagnostic processes. Alerts cover diagnostics that are determined not to affect the transmitter's ability to output the correct measurement signal reflecting the process variable (PV) and therefore will not interrupt the 4-20 mA or digital fieldbus output. A typical example of an alert could be "PV out-of-range."

Alarms cover diagnostics that are determined to affect the transmitter's ability to output an accurate PV value of the measurement. Detected alarms will drive the transmitter output either high or low depending on the user's configuration choice. Alerts and alarms can be sent to the control system, read on a local indicator, on a field communicator, or on a HART-compliant monitoring system as seen in Figure 1.

Accessing diagnostic information

Alerts and alarms can be sent to the control system, read on a local indicator, on a field communicator, or on a HART-compliant monitoring system. Courtesy: Emerson Process ManagementAt a basic level, transmitters with display options will present certain diagnostic messages. Typically, the field operator will routinely check these displays and report any diagnostic conditions to the control system technician group.

The most frequently deployed transmitters communicate using 4-20 mA with HART. This allows them to send a large amount of operational and diagnostic data via the HART signal that is superimposed on the analog output signal of the transmitter. Any or all of this data may be accessed via:

  • A hand-held field communicator
  • A HART-enabled capability in the DCS I/O systems to extract and monitor the HART data, and
  • A HART-enabled asset management system.

As with traditional wired HART transmitters described above, that same information can be sent using a WirelessHART transmitter or one using ISA100.11a. For Foundation fieldbus and Profibus systems, the operational and diagnostic information available is also very extensive.

The operations-maintenance relationship

Close coordination between operators and technicians to review diagnostic information routinely enables quick identification and resolution of problem situations before they can adversely impact production. One example is in relation to a dual sensor redundant measurement. If an operator gets a diagnostic message that the secondary sensor has been initiated for a transmitter, he or she knows that the primary sensor has failed and that the measurement is now coming from the secondary sensor. By alerting the maintenance technician, the failed sensor can be replaced, thus restoring the measurement redundancy capability.

Another example is regarding when the PV is out of limits. An operator receives a "PV out of limits" alert where the HART transmitter is reporting that the primary variable read by the transmitter is outside of the 4-20 mA range. This signal could focus the technician on troubleshooting open or short circuits in the transmitter wiring. Yet another example is regarding analog-digital mismatch. The HART transmitter is reporting a difference between the analog 4-20 mA signal and the digital primary PV signal. This functionality can be used to determine a small ground leakage in the home-run cable to the instrument or an intermittent device. If a small ground leakage exists in the loop, any alarm trip limit of the loop may never be reached, even under trip conditions, due to earth leakage from the signal.

Avoiding the biggest issues

The three biggest issues that diagnostics help you to avoid are measurement failure, poor measurement reliability, and suboptimal process control.

Measurement failure occurs when any of the components of the overall temperature system fail. Temperature sensors are relatively delicate and are exposed to the harsh process environment, making them more susceptible to failure than the other components. The use of redundancy, drift detection, and monitoring of the measurement instrument's diagnostics all help to identify and address sensor degradation or failure.

Many benefits can be gained by using diagnostics in a manufacturing process. Courtesy: Emerson Process ManagementMeasurement reliability is key to minimizing disruptions to the process. The temperature measurement system should be designed to minimize or eliminate the problems caused by sensor degradation, electrically noisy environments, or instrument failure to ensure a reliable measurement. The design should use such features as noise filtering, measurement validation, drifting sensor identification, and alerts for broken or loose sensor leads.

The ultimate goal of providing an accurate and reliable measurement signal is to ensure process control reliably keeps the process within its predetermined limits. The diligent use of transmitter diagnostic features can identify situations where these limits are violated and identify and quantify the deviations. They can identify intermittent sensor failures, record minimum and maximum process temperatures, and log failures and their causes. Using this information can support rapid response to address identified issues, so as to ensure optimal process control is maintained.

Each approach has its own benefits

Many benefits can be gained by using diagnostics in a manufacturing process. A few have been outlined in Chart 1. For example, measurement failure is related to sensor failure. As mentioned earlier, sensors are relatively delicate, but for the sake of getting the most accurate readings, they must be exposed to the often harsh process environment, making them more susceptible to failure than the other components. Without an accurate and reliable measurement signal, control will be sub-optimal and the system will be unable to keep the process within predetermined limits.

The bottom line

Judicious use of the diagnostics available in almost every temperature measurement system provides a return on this investment (ROI) in proportion to the criticality of the measurement. The investment is mostly in time spent, and the ROI may be measured in increased throughput, higher product quality, less downtime, less product waste, lower energy costs, or more subjectively, prevention of an explosion.

Your instrumentation provides the means to look into the process. Using diagnostics provides a way to keep that window clean.

Michelle Weimert is a senior manager, temperature marketing and product development, for Emerson Process Management.

Key concepts:

  • Diagnostic information from smart transmitters can warn of problems developing with a process sensor.
  • The physical delicacy of temperature sensors makes them particularly susceptible to damage or degradation.
  • Your ability to control a process depends on the accuracy and reliability of your instrumentation. Diagnostics help ensure that reliability.

ONLINE 

This is the fifth part of this temperature series. Read the earlier installments below.

To learn more about measuring temperature in process manufacturing applications, go to www.rosemount.com/tempguide and order a free copy of The Engineer's Guide to Industrial Temperature Measurement.

www.emersonprocess.com 

Subscribe to the Process Instrumentation & Sensors Monthly eNewsletter 



FREDERICK , NY, United States, 03/24/14 01:12 PM:

instant-electro-magnetic-force "i-EMF" sensor is now a commercial market product.
A [(Temp + Press)emf SUM]is now possible to know the TOTAL emf in a VACUUM to PRESSURE state. The rate of MASS flow rate is KNOWN
Anonymous , 04/01/14 12:22 PM:

I agree that over and above the temperature measurement for the control loop, a temperature transmitter should also provide diagnostics for the sensor element as well as the transmitter itself.

The best way to make use of the device diagnostics is through real-time diagnostics monitoring from intelligent device management (IDM) software part of the asset management system (AMS). For HART devices the diagnostics polling time has to be set sufficiently fast to report the problem sufficiently early for operators to tend the process on sensor or device failure, before the process is affected. For FOUNDATION fieldbus devices the diagnostics is reported almost immediately.

User friendly task-based “dashboards” device user interfaces based on human centered design principles make devices using different protocols look & feel consistent, almost the same; a fieldbus device is as user friendly as a 4-20 mA device, but they are not the same. There are differences in the diagnostics and computational features they provide, but they are operated in the same basic way. In some devices the diagnostics is the same for both versions. Theoretically diagnostics is independent of the communication protocol. However, for many two-wire devices there is a difference in diagnostics for another reason. Bus-powered FOUNDATION fieldbus devices are capable of more advanced diagnostics than their two-wire 4-20 mA loop-powered counterparts because Fieldbus devices may have additional electronic circuitry, more frequent tests, and have more powerful microprocessors enabling more sophisticated diagnostics firmware. This is possible because bus powered Fieldbus devices are allowed to consume more power (> 10 mA) than loop powered 4-20 mA (< 4 mA) devices.

For instance, the Fieldbus version of a temperature transmitter may have Statistical Process Monitoring (SPM). SPM is able to detect abnormal process behavior before operation constraints are reached, providing an early warning. SPM alarm provides process engineers with a better view of what is going on in the process. It may be used to detect hydrate formation in natural gas lines, scaling formation, and thermowells coating etc. This can be used for daily maintenance and turnaround planning.

Learn more about intelligent device management (IDM) in general, and device diagnostics in particular, from the tutorial and work process guide found here:
http://www.eddl.org/DeviceManagement/Pages/DeviceDiagnostics.aspx
Jonas , Singapore, 07/06/14 12:10 PM:

Temperature transmitters also support Statistical Process Monitoring (SPM). SPM is able to detect abnormal process behavior before operation constraints are reached, providing an early warning. SPM provides process engineers with a better view of what is going on in the process. It may be used to detect hydrate formation in natural gas lines, scaling formation, and thermowell coating etc. Learn more about device diagnostics and intelligent device management (IDM) software part of asset management systems and how diagnostics is incorporated in daily maintenance and turnaround planning here:

http://www.eddl.org/DeviceManagement/Pages/DeviceDiagnostics.aspx
Jonas , Singapore, 07/20/14 11:36 AM:

Statistical Process Monitoring (SPM) is able to detect abnormal process behavior before operation constraints are reached, providing an early warning. AnSPM alarm provides process engineers with a better view of what is going on in the process. It may be used to detect hydrate formation in natural gas lines, scaling formation, and thermowell coating etc. Learn more about diagnostics and intelligent device management (IDM) from the tutorial and guide found here:
http://www.eddl.org/DeviceManagement/Pages/DeviceDiagnostics.aspx
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by...
The System Integrator Giants program lists the top 100 system integrators among companies listed in CFE Media's Global System Integrator Database.
The Engineering Leaders Under 40 program identifies and gives recognition to young engineers who...
This eGuide illustrates solutions, applications and benefits of machine vision systems.
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
Save energy with automation; Process control system upgrades; Dispelling controll myths; Time-sensitive networking; Control system integration; Road to IANA
Additive manufacturing advancements; Machine vision enhances robotics; Fieldbus evolution; Process safety; Advice from System Integrators of the Year; Road to IANA
Salary and career survey: Benchmarks and advice; Designing controls; Remote data collection, historians; Control valve advances; Hannover Messe; Control Engineering International
This article collection contains several articles on the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) and how it is transforming manufacturing.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

The digital oilfield: Utilizing Big Data can yield big savings; Virtualization a real solution; Tracking SIS performance
Getting to the bottom of subsea repairs: Older pipelines need more attention, and operators need a repair strategy; OTC preview; Offshore production difficult - and crucial
Digital oilfields: Integrated HMI/SCADA systems enable smarter data acquisition; Real-world impact of simulation; Electric actuator technology prospers in production fields
click me