Energy, Power

Low battery self-discharge: the hidden secret to long operating life

While much media attention has been focused on extending battery operating life through the use of low-power chipsets and communication protocols, the potential energy savings gained from all of these schemes fails to compare with the energy lost to annual self-discharge.
By Sol Jacobs September 28, 2019
Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Remote wireless devices used in industrial automation and the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) increasingly require the use of long-life lithium batteries to ensure reliable performance and to reduce the total cost of ownership.

Powering these devices with industrial-grade lithium batteries can eliminate the need for hard-wiring devices to the power grid, which is prohibitively expensive, costing roughly $100/ft for any type of hard-wired device, even a basic electrical switch. These costs can rise exponentially in hard-to-access locations.

If a remote wireless device draws an average current in microamps, it typically can be powered for extended periods using an industrial-grade primary (non-rechargeable) lithium battery. If the device draws an average current in milliamps, then it may be better suited for some type of energy harvesting device in conjunction with a Lithium-ion (Li-ion) rechargeable battery to store the harvested energy.

Lithium thionyl chloride batteries last longer

Lithium batteries feature a high intrinsic negative potential that exceeds all other metals. As the lightest non-gaseous metal, lithium offers the highest specific energy (energy per unit weight) and energy density (energy per unit volume) of all available battery chemistries. Lithium cells operate within a normal operating current voltage (OCV) range of 2.7 to 3.6 V. These chemistries also are nonaqueous, making them less likely to freeze in extreme temperatures.

Numerous primary lithium chemistries are commercially available, including iron disulfate (LiFeS2), lithium manganese dioxide (LiMnO2), lithium thionyl chloride (LiSOCl2) and lithium metal-oxide. Of all these alternatives, LiSOCl2 chemistry is preferred for long-term deployments involving extreme environments, including AMR/AMI metering, machine-to-machine (M2M), supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA), tank-level monitoring, asset tracking and environmental sensors, to name a few.

Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries feature the highest capacity and highest energy density of any lithium battery, which supports product miniaturization. These batteries also feature a low annual self-discharge rate (under 1% per year for certain cells), permitting up to 40-year battery life. Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries also offer the widest possible temperature range (-80 to 125 C), and are made with a superior glass-to-metal hermetic seal that resists leakage (see Figure 1).

Figure 1: Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries have been proven to last up to 40 years in certain low power applications. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 1: Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries have been proven to last up to 40 years in certain low power applications. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Specially modified bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries are used in the cold chain to continuously monitor the transport of frozen foods, pharmaceuticals, tissue samples and transplant organs at -80 C. Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries also are uniquely adaptable to high temperatures. For example, these batteries power active RFID tags that track the location and status of medical equipment without having to remove the battery prior to autoclave sterilization, where temperatures can reach 125 C (see Figure 2).

Figure 2: Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries allow medical RFID tags to undergo high temperature autoclave sterilization without having to remove the battery. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 2: Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries allow medical RFID tags to undergo high temperature autoclave sterilization without having to remove the battery. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Lower self-discharge is crucial

While much media attention has been focused on extending battery operating life through the use of low-power chipsets and communication protocols, the potential energy savings gained from all of these schemes fails to compare with the energy lost to annual self-discharge.

Self-discharge is a natural phenomenon that affects all batteries, as chemical reactions occur even when the battery is in storage and not being used. Self-discharge rates vary based on a number of factors, including the current discharge potential of the cell based on its design, the purity and quality of the raw materials and the ability of the battery manufacturer to control cell passivation, thereby slowing down the chemical reactions that lead to self-discharge.

Understanding passivation

Passivation is a thin film of lithium chloride (LiCl) that forms on the surface of the lithium anode, creating a high resistance layer between the electrodes, thereby restricting the chemical reactions that cause self-discharge. When a load is placed on the cell, the passivation layer causes higher resistance, which can cause the cell’s voltage to dip temporarily until the discharge reaction slowly removes the passivation layer. This process repeats itself each time the load is removed.

Figure 3: Bottle examples: low flow/ low self-discharge (a); Medium flow/ medium self-discharge (b); High flow/ high self-discharge (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 3: Bottle examples: low flow/ low self-discharge (a); Medium flow/ medium self-discharge (b); High flow/ high self-discharge (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Different factors can influence the amount of passivation, including the current capacity of the cell, length of storage, storage temperature, discharge temperature and prior discharge conditions, as partially discharging a cell and then removing the load increases the amount of passivation relative to when the cell was new.

Better batteries balance passivation and energy discharge

Passivation is essential for reducing battery self-discharge, but too much of it can restrict energy from flowing when its needed most. Conversely, less passivation permits a greater rate of energy flow, but the tradeoff is a higher self-discharge rate and a shorter operating life.

Comparing the effect of passivation on self-discharge and energy flow is like comparing bottles of fluid with different size openings (see Figures 3 – 7 and Figure 9):

  • The volume of the glass/bottle is equivalent to battery capacity
  • Evaporation/self-discharge is equivalent to capacity loss
  • Flow volume is equal to discharge/energy flow
  • Low liquid/electrolyte quality can cause the opening to get plugged up, which can cause flow stoppage/passivation
  • Low liquid/electrolyte quality can cause evaporation/self-discharge
  • Bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries have very “small openings”
  • LiMnO2 and alkaline batteries have “larger openings” that permit higher flow rates but also result in faster evaporation/self-discharge
  • Large openings are good for fast flow/discharge but not for storing fluids for a long time
  • For long operating life you need a small opening for low evaporation/self-discharge
  • Opening size/battery design is a critical issue – too large an opening can cause too much evaporation/self-discharge; too small an opening and there is no flow and the opening can be clogged (passivation)
  • Fluid/chemistry quality is imperative to keeping impurities/passivation low.

How to deliver low self-discharge and high flow/pulses

Remote wireless devices increasingly require periodic high pulses to power two-way wireless communications and other advanced functionality. These requirements invariably draw additional current, so various methods are used to conserve energy, including low-power communications protocols (ZigBee, WirelessHART, LoRa, etc.), low-power microprocessors and more efficient data sampling and transmission.

Figure 4: Comparative flow rates: XOL TL-49xx Series (a); IXTRA TL-59xx Series and other manufacturers (b); LiMnO2 and alkaline cells (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 4: Comparative flow rates: XOL TL-49xx Series (a); IXTRA TL-59xx Series and other manufacturers (b); LiMnO2 and alkaline cells (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Standard bobbin-type LiSOCl2 batteries are not designed to deliver high pulses due to their low rate design. However, this can be solved easily by using a patented hybrid layer capacitor (HLC). The standard bobbin-type LiSOCl2 cell delivers low daily background current while the HLC handles periodic high pulses. The patented HLC also features a special end-of-life voltage plateau that can be interpreted to deliver automatic low-battery status alerts (see Figure 8).

Figure 5: Comparative evaporation/self-discharge rates: XOL TL-49xx Series (a); IXTRA TL-59xx Series and other manufacturers (b); LiMnO2 and alkaline cells (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 5: Comparative evaporation/self-discharge rates: XOL TL-49xx Series (a); IXTRA TL-59xx Series and other manufacturers (b); LiMnO2 and alkaline cells (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Supercapacitors deliver high pulses electrostatically rather than through a chemical reaction. While popular for use in consumer electronics, supercapacitors generally are unsuited for industrial applications due to inherent drawbacks such as short-duration power, linear discharge qualities that prevent use of all the available energy, low capacity, low energy density and high annual self-discharge rates (up to 60% per year). Supercapacitors linked in series also require the use of cell-balancing circuits, which add to their cost and bulkiness and consumes energy to further raise their self-discharge rate (see Figure 9).

Figure 6: Volume left after 10 and 20 years of self-discharge only (no load): XOL TL-49xx Series (a); IXTRA TL-59xx Series and other manufacturers, generally not recommended for applications requiring more than 10 years of operating life where the average daily current drawn to operate the device plus the annual self-discharge rate will deplete cell capacity to a point so low that it compromises long-term reliability (b); LiMnO2 and alkaline cells, high annual self-discharge rates make 10+year battery life impossible (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 6: Volume left after 10 and 20 years of self-discharge only (no load): XOL TL-49xx Series (a); IXTRA TL-59xx Series and other manufacturers, generally not recommended for applications requiring more than 10 years of operating life where the average daily current drawn to operate the device plus the annual self-discharge rate will deplete cell capacity to a point so low that it compromises long-term reliability (b); LiMnO2 and alkaline cells, high annual self-discharge rates make 10+year battery life impossible (c). Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Testing for annual self-discharge can be misleading

The long-term impact of a battery with a higher self-discharge rate may not become apparent for years, and theoretical methods for predicting actual battery life generally under-represent the importance of the passivation effect along with long-term exposure to extreme temperatures.

Figure 7: Clogged openings – passivation – prevent flow. Low quality fluid/electrolyte can freeze in the opening in cold and can plug up the opening in the heat. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 7: Clogged openings – passivation – prevent flow. Low quality fluid/electrolyte can freeze in the opening in cold and can plug up the opening in the heat. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

If your application demands long-life power, then you need to conduct proper due diligence by thoroughly evaluating potential battery suppliers. This process starts by demanding fully documented long-term test results along with long-term in-field test data and customer references from real-life devices operating under similar loads and environmental conditions.

Figure 8: PulsesPlus batteries combine a standard bobbin-type LiSOCl2 battery with a patented hybrid layer capacitor (HLC) to deliver the periodic high pulses required for two-way wireless communications. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 8: PulsesPlus batteries combine a standard bobbin-type LiSOCl2 battery with a patented hybrid layer capacitor (HLC) to deliver the periodic high pulses required for two-way wireless communications. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

For example, accurate long-term test data is essential to specifying batteries for AMR/AMI utility meter transmitters, as a large-scale battery failure can disrupt customer billing systems and disable remote service start-up and shut-off capabilities. The city of Springfield, Mass., learned this lesson the hard way, as the municipality was forced to begin prematurely replacing thousands of water meter batteries each year to avoid the potential of a mass disruption to its automated billing systems (see Figure 10).

Further considerations

When specifying an industrial-grade lithium battery, various technical requirements should be factored in, including: the amount of current consumed in active mode (along with the size, duration and frequency of pulses); energy consumed in standby or sleep mode (the base current); storage time (as normal self-discharge during storage diminishes capacity); expected temperatures (including during storage and in-field operation); equipment cut-off voltage (as battery capacity is exhausted, or in extreme temperatures, voltage can drop to a point too low for the sensor to operate); and the annual self-discharge rate of the battery (which can approach the amount of current drawn from average daily use).

Figure 9: XOL/HLC in action: Heavy flow upon discharge. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 9: XOL/HLC in action: Heavy flow upon discharge. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

A top-quality bobbin-type LiSOCl2 battery can enable certain low power devices to operate for up to 40 years, achieving a low cost of ownership due to a very low annual self-discharge rate.

When calculating your projected cost of ownership, make sure to include all anticipated expenses, including future battery replacements over the lifetime of the device, as well as calculating the added costs and risks associated with premature battery failure.

Figure 10: AMR/AMI meter transmitter units (MTU) are often buried underground, exposed to extreme temperatures and difficult to access for replacement. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

Figure 10: AMR/AMI meter transmitter units (MTU) are often buried underground, exposed to extreme temperatures and difficult to access for replacement. Courtesy: Tadiran Batteries

When extended battery life is essential, remember that theoretical claims regarding battery life are often misleading by failing to properly measure the passivation effect and energy losses caused by long-term exposure to extreme temperatures. So, do your due diligence.

Sol Jacobs is vice president and general manager, Tadiran Batteries.

This article appears in the Applied Automation supplement for Control Engineering and Plant Engineering.


Sol Jacobs
Author Bio: Sol Jacobs is vice president and general manager, Tadiran Batteries.