Sn-Ag-Cu: key to a lead-free Europe…and world
Ames, IA —Lead has long been recognized as a highly toxic material that can cause brain damage. Its use in paint was banned in 1978 and it was later removed from gasoline to further protect human health. But a burgeoning source—electronic waste—poses a substantial new environmental threat as lead and other chemicals leach from computers, cell phones, and other electronic devices being buried in landfills. Though computer circuit boards contain only small amounts of lead solder, the problem is overall volume. By some estimates, about 3,000 tons of electronic waste is discarded daily just in the U.S.
Beginning July 1, the European Union will strictly limit the amount of lead and other hazardous materials in newly sold electronic appliances’ circuitry. However, given the electronics industry’s globalism, the European ban effectively is international in scope. As electronics and appliance manufacturers scramble to meet those tough new restrictions, a lead-free solder developed at the U.S. Dept. of Energy’s Ames Laboratory is playing a key role.
Composed of lead and tin, traditional solder melts and flows easily, but sets up quickly to create a strong, durable bond between the mating surfaces. A solder blend of 63% tin and 37% lead, results in a eutectic alloy—behaving like a pure metal with a single melting and solidification point.
“Finding a substitute for lead that gave the solder similar properties was difficult,” said Ames Laboratory’s senior metallurgist, Iver Anderson. “With our basic understanding of alloys, we developed a tin-silver-copper alloy that offered a lower melting temperature and greater strength than other lead-free alternatives being considered.”
Ames Laboratory’s solder technology was patented in 1996 and over 60 companies worldwide have licensed Ames Lab’s lead-free solder, according to Ken Kirkland, executive director of the Iowa State University Research Foundation. To date, those licenses have generated royalties exceeding $5 million.
“With the European directives and a similar commercial initiative in Japan, we’ve seen a growing interest in the alloy,” Kirkland said. “The technology was a little ahead of its time, but it’s an excellent product and we have a strong patent; you can’t ask for a better combination than that.”
The Ames Lab solder is just one of several lead-free alternatives on the market. The type and specific composition of lead-free solder also depends on the soldering technique used and the end application. In addition to the tin-silver-copper alloy, Anderson’s group developed modified alloys that also contained iron, cobalt, and other similar elements. This blend is suitable for higher temperature applications and has also been patented.
One ongoing problem with lead-free alternatives now available is a tendency for embrittlement over time after repeated or prolonged heating cycles. And heat has become a growing factor as technological advances have boosted operating temperatures. For example, the steady climb in computer processor speeds has meant a corresponding increase in the amount of heat they generate. And computers aren’t the only devices that generate heat.
“Even the circuitry in your cell phone operates at about 125 oC,” Anderson said, “and over six months’ use, that can mean several hundred hours of high temperatures. If you drop it now, the solder joints have become more brittle and the risk of it ‘breaking’ is higher.”
To combat this solder “aging” problem, Anderson’s group has recently been studying more additives to the tin-silver-copper formula, including silicon, titanium, chromium, manganese, nickel, zinc and germanium. Joints soldered with the different alloys were subjected to 150 oC for 1,000 hours, then tested for both shear and impact strengths.
“Zinc appears to be most attractive in terms of retained ductility and strength,” Anderson said, “and also offers benefits in terms of solder-ability, ease of alloying and material cost.” While additional testing is needed, he added that the tin-silver-copper-zinc composition is covered under the original patent.
One other benefit of this recent work is development of a simple technique for characterizing the bulk composition of solder joints using an electron microprobe. This permits Anderson’s research team to analyze the new compositions being studied under different soldering conditions.
“With the elimination of lead, tin-silver-copper solders are here for the long-run,” Anderson said. “But that doesn’t mean we’ll stop trying to improve our basic understanding of how these alloys work in order to improve their performance.”
Iowa State University operates the Ames Laboratory for the U.S. Dept. of Energy.
For more information visit www.ameslab.gov .