Understanding Valve Actuator Diagnostics

Electric motor-operated valve actuators can tell you a lot about their condition if you take advantage of sophisticated diagnostics available from current designs combined with networking protocols. This tutorial can help you put those capabilities to work. Link to related articles.
By B. Scott Wilkerson, Flowserve November 1, 2009

Related Control Engineering feature articles:

Partial Stroke Testing ;
The Art of Instrumentation ; – Advances in Control Loop Optimization .

For more information, visit:

Constant diagnostic evaluation of electric motor-operated valves (MOVs) has become an important tool for asset management, predictive maintenance programs, troubleshooting, and scheduled periodic maintenance. Predictive functionality allows your maintenance personnel to be proactive in servicing MOVs, while limiting costly failures and unscheduled plant process shutdowns. During scheduled downtime, maintenance personnel are given the information they need to prioritize valve and actuator maintenance to make best use of scarce opportunities.

Improvements in diagnostics

Diagnostic testing of electrically actuated valves began nearly 30 years ago to validate the operability of safety-related MOVs in the nuclear power industry. Since this periodic, manually-initiated form of diagnostic testing could identify problems in both the valve and actuator, it became not only a tool to verify MOV operation, but also for troubleshooting and preventive maintenance.

Dashboards show the condition and functionality of every valve in the program.

Dashboards show the condition and functionality of every valve in the program.

A typical GUI for a single valve.

A typical GUI for a single valve.

In recent years, innovations within electronic smart actuation devices created a highly sophisticated but labor-intensive troubleshooting effort for plant personnel. To overcome the labor intensity, built-in-self-test (BIST) features, developed in conjunction with customer requirements, have removed the manual initiation and transformed the historical periodic diagnostic testing into a continuous process, performed integrally within the electric actuator, as shown in the diagnostic system dashboard graphic.

Today, electric valve actuators served by digital communication networks are commonplace among new plant installations. This is partly due to recent advances in electric actuators that allow them to process more diagnostic information than comparable pneumatic models. Much of the current innovation effort of electric actuators is aimed at providing more diagnostic information to the end user.

Using FDT and EDDL

While advantages resulting from networking actuators are numerous, the main objective for maintenance and asset managers is to receive detailed diagnostic data in a clear, precise, and timely manner so they can take appropriate actions in order to avoid plant shutdown conditions. Due to the depth of device knowledge required for diagnostic development, the device manufacturer should perform precise packaging of the data for proper transmission across a digital communication network for display in the plant’s diagnostic software. Due to the unique characteristics and failure modes of the different units that make up modern process systems, the device manufacturer is able to design diagnostic strategies able to evaluate each unit specifically, rather than using generic scripts based on equipment types that could be misleading.

The packaging of device-specific diagnostic information for network communications should be developed to operate on two complementary device integration platforms: Field Device Tool/Device Type Manager (FDT/DTM) and Electronic Device Description Language (EDDL). Both of these can use fieldbus networks, such as Foundation Fieldbus or Profibus, to transport data from the field to the end user.

FDT/DTM allows data exchange between primary control systems or engineering/asset management tools (FDTs) and device-specific software components (DTMs). Actuators and valves can be operated, configured, monitored, and diagnosed through the DTMs integrated in the FDT frame. The graphical user interface (GUI) supports advanced views through an FDT-compliant interface.

EDDL allows data exchange between host control systems or engineering/asset management tools and device-specific software components known as Device Description (DD) files. The DD file is provided in a plain-text format that can be opened with word-processing applications. This file is integrated into the host control system for operation, configuration, monitoring, and diagnosing the field unit.

Both platforms offer many benefits, including a GUI for alarms, histograms, charts and graphs, and other relevant data when integrated into a MOV digital network. Device manufacturers support both technologies and will likely continue to do so. A given end user will typically choose one or the other platform based on preferences related to larger control system suppliers, fieldbus architectures, and instrumentation conventions. Some technologies are closely aligned and tend to be used together.

Networked motor-operated valves can be of all sizes and applications in a large plant environment. Source: Flowserve Limitorque

Networked motor-operated valves can be of all sizes and applications in a large plant environment. Source: Flowserve Limitorque

Using prepackaged data

Regardless of the platform utilized by a given plant, the critical component for successful diagnostic deployments lies with the device manufacturer’s software development techniques. One of these techniques is to prepackage the data prior to passing it along via one of the device integration platforms operating on a fieldbus network.

Building a diagnostic engine software component, with prepackaged diagnostic analysis capabilities within the electric actuator, permits you to access multiple types of valve and actuator diagnostic information visually that is meaningful to different departments within your organization. By following the NAMUR NE-107 standard, a Foundation Fieldbus diagnostic specification based on guidelines established by the NAMUR Working Group 2.6, during development an end user is able to classify each valve and actuator alert, alarm, and diagnostic condition as a failure, off-specification, maintenance, or check function. The data is then routed to the appropriate plant personnel.

Some modern electric actuator systems allow access to condition data and alarms on a local display or on Bluetooth-enabled devices. This provides easy access to valve and actuator data as the software used on the Bluetooth device provides access to the most often used functions of the full FDT/DTM or EDDL interface. The graphic on P3 shows an example of a mobile device interface.

Valve diagnostic parameters

Valve-specific diagnostics allow you to monitor the health of all valves and actuators in a plant or process. By gathering, analyzing, and packaging results inside the electric actuator, you can monitor a valve’s health. A valve warning prior to a critical failure gives your maintenance personnel time to repair the valve without unscheduled shutdowns and loss of productivity.

Many operating parameters can serve as indicators of a valve’s health, including:

  • The actuator’s torque trend during valve travel;

  • Capturing the valve cycle count; and

  • Monitoring the valve’s span of travel.

When evaluating the actuator’s torque trend, a nominal base-line is established and then an ongoing comparative analysis is performed.

A low-torque condition will prompt warnings and/or alarms normally associated with a broken valve stem or plug, seat leaking, flashing, packing wear, sheared key, or damaged stem-to-stem nut interface.

A high-torque situation reveals valve issues such as seat wear, obstruction, gumming, extreme vibration, inadequate stem lubrication, excessively tightened packing, or other mechanical issues.

Capturing the valve cycle or operation count allows maintenance to assess usage, while prompting a service reminder after a user-assigned count set point has been reached. This quickly helps the maintenance engineer determine if excessive wear conditions exist and service is required.

Diagnosing the span of valve travel over a period of time validates important attributes associated with the valve, including correct sizing and range of performance. For optimum modulating performance, the majority of valve operation should be positioned near 50% open. Naturally, open/close valve applications should reveal a normal distribution between 0% and 100% open. Skewed data in one direction or the other suggests a valve that may not be optimally sized for the application. Typical flow conditions are as important as pipe size for valve selection.

Actuator diagnostics

Actuator-specific data gathered within the device should include information on standard key components, such as the electric motor, mechanical gearing, position encoder, torque sensor, and motor controller/contactor. The actuator’s BIST feature analyzes component-related data in order to determine overall actuator health.

By gathering the motor supply voltage, current, winding temperature, and runtime, you will be able to see the electric motor performance measures clearly. Individual user-configurable thresholds provide direction for generating motor warnings and alarms. For example, a high-motor-current condition can signal impending issues such as motor failure, loss of mechanical-gear efficiency, and low-line voltage.

Encoders are typically used in electric actuators to enable precise valve positioning, so it is extremely important to integrate encoder diagnostics into the actuator. These components are either absolute or incremental rotary-style encoders using optical or mechanical sensing technologies. Optical encoders typically use LEDs beamed onto photodiodes through slits in a disc. Mechanical encoders typically employ strips of magnetized material placed on a rotating disc interacting with a Hall-effect sensor.

Redundancy in encoder/sensor design allows the BIST feature to discern if a specific electronic component failure merits only a warning or an alarm plus safe shutdown of the actuator. For motor control, most electric actuators use either a mechanical-reversing contactor or a solid-state motor controller. There are more diagnostic capabilities when the solid-state device is included, because its microprocessor-based software can monitor detailed performance characteristics associated with the motor-driver insulated-gate bipolar transistor (IGBT), internal RAM and bus communications.

Innovative design techniques have been developed to ensure actuator mechanical-reversing contactors have diagnostics and safeguards to protect against erroneous operation. By continually analyzing dedicated signal lines associated with the motor reversing contactor relay drive transistor, the actuator can eliminate unexpected erroneous actuation caused by internal electronic failures and erratic external command signals, as well as report current status, alarms, and the actuator’s health.

Saving time, money

There are countless diagnostic-testing techniques that can be performed for MOVs, including partial stroke and emergency shutdown tests. Valves and actuators should be equipped with the core requirements for continuous embedded-device testing while installed in industrial applications.

As plant asset management systems continue to expand, an electric actuator that monitors MOV health indicators and communicates the results in a user-friendly fashion is just as essential as actuating the valve. This information helps you and your maintenance staff minimize unplanned downtime and prioritize maintenance during scheduled outages to increase the profitability of your facility.


Author Information
B. Scott Wilkerson is senior product manager for Flowserve Flow Control Division.

Want this article on your website? Click here to sign up for a free account in ContentStream® and make that happen.