Six questions to ask when choosing an open- or closed-loop hydraulic system

Choosing an open-loop or closed-loop hydraulic system is not easy and taking the time to look at the big picture design intentions and understand the system will save the user many potential headaches.

04/28/2017


If someone talks about an open-loop or closed-loop hydraulic system, what exactly do they mean? Fundamentally, the difference can be described in just two sentences, and is most easily defined by the pump: An open-loop pump draws all of its flow directly from a reservoir and sends the majority of it directly back to the reservoir after performing its function. A closed-loop pump draws most of its flow directly from the return flow of its actuator(s).

Unfortunately, the pros, cons, and implications of each are not quite as easy to summarize and understand. In order to avoid the pain and consequences of choosing the wrong type of circuit for your application, it is wise to think about the big picture design intentions and analyze the merits of each approach.

Before attempting to make this decision, consider these questions:

1. What type and how many actuators are needed?

If you are providing flow to cylinders, the user most likely don't want a closed loop. This is because the volume entering one side of a single rod cylinder does not equal the volume going out of the other side. One side or the other would experience a pressure spike or cavitation due to these unequal volumes working against each other. A double rod cylinder could theoretically work until the cylinder reached end-of-stroke. It would be a very uncommon situation in which you could benefit from a closed loop providing flow to cylinders.

Hydraulic motors are the typical actuators in a closed loop. They generally operate bi-directionally and must have some special features to be appropriate. A loop flushing valve and/or relief valves can be built into a closed-loop motor. This can eliminate the need for other such components that would have to be installed separately.

2. How much space is available?

A closed-loop circuit can operate smoothly in forward and reverse directions without a directional valve being involved. This eliminates the need for the valve component, which can be costly and take up valuable real estate on mobile equipment. This also cuts down on hose and fitting complexity and space.

The closed-loop pump is usually a piston pump that is capable of varying between forward, zero, and reverse flow. The swashplate controls this output by pivoting over center.

A closed loop generally requires a much smaller reservoir as well, since most of the fluid is being recirculated in the loop rather than endlessly sucked up and spit back into the tank. The only fluid that comes from the tank is that which is feeding the charge pump. More on that in the discussion of temperature further down.

3. Is the components' weight a factor?

Similarly to the ability of a closed-loop system to take up less space, it generally has a much lower total weight. The largest weight savings can be realized when the reservoir and oil volume can be reduced.

4. Is hydrostatic braking needed?

A key feature (or challenge) of a closed-loop system, especially in vehicle propel applications, is the existence of hydrostatic braking. When driving a car, if the foot moves off the accelerator, the car will continue to coast (assuming the car is an automatic...).

If the user lets off the accelerator pedal with a closed-loop propel system, the vehicle will come to an abrupt stop. This can be an advantage because it often eliminates the need for service brakes. However, this feature is undesirable in cases where high speed is involved and the input device has a quick spring return design. If the operator's foot were to accidentally slip off the pedal or input device, the machine could violently stop and send him or her flying forward without proper restraint.

5. Does the system require an oil cooler for temperature reduction?

A closed loop will generally operate at a higher temperature than a similar open loop. This is because most of the oil is recirculated and does not have as much time or exposure to conductors such as tank walls and hosing. However, a closed loop can offer the most effective cooling performance for heat exchangers by offering a high temperature differential.

If a mobile machine has both an open and closed loop circuit, along with an oil cooler, then the case drains and flushing valve(s) in the closed loop will enable the bulk of the total heat rejection because of the resulting higher overall "delta T."

6. How precisely do the pump's functions need to be controlled? 

When a closed-loop pump is commanded to stroke in either direction, it is metering oil into either side of the actuator via "positive displacement." This is more precise and controllable than any valve by nature. A valve opens and closes a small passage and "throttles" flow through a restriction. A piston pump is injecting fluid one piston at a time into the loop and will have inherently better and more consistent control.

With mobile machinery, the best answer is often a combination of open and closed loop circuits running at the same time to perform all of the desired functions. A piece of equipment may have 20 cylinders raising, lowering, extending, etc. It is often most cost effective and best to choose a closed loop for certain specific functions, and provide flow to the rest with an open-loop pump and valving.

David Saunders is an account manager with Cross Company. He has over 20 years of experience in the process control industries in business development and management roles. This article originally appeared on Cross Company's Mobile Hydraulic & Control Systems blog. Edited by Chris Vavra, production editor, Control Engineering, CFE Media, cvavra@cfemedia.com.

Cross Company is a CSIA member as of 2/2/2017



The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by Control Engineering subscribers. Vote now (if qualified)!
The System Integrator Giants program lists the top 100 system integrators among companies listed in CFE Media's Global System Integrator Database.
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering and Plant Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners in three categories.
This eGuide illustrates solutions, applications and benefits of machine vision systems.
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
HMI effectiveness; Distributed I/O; Engineers' Choice Award finalists; System Integrator advice; Inside Machines
Women in engineering; Engineering Leaders Under 40; PID benefits and drawbacks; Ladder logic; Cloud computing
Robotic integration and cloud connections; SCADA and cybersecurity; Motor efficiency standards; Open- and closed-loop control; Augmented reality
Programmable logic controllers (PLCs) represent the logic (decision) part of the control loop of sense, decide, and actuate. As we know, PLCs aren’t the only option for making decisions in a control loop, but they are likely why you’re here.
This digital report explains how motion control advances and solutions can help with machine control, automated control on assembly lines, integration of robotics and automation, and machine safety.
This article collection contains several articles on how advancements in vision system designs, computing power, algorithms, optics, and communications are making machine vision more cost effective than ever before.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

Control room technology innovation; Practical approaches to corrosion protection; Pipeline regulator revises quality programs
Cloud, mobility, and remote operations; SCADA and contextual mobility; Custom UPS empowering a secure pipeline
Infrastructure for natural gas expansion; Artificial lift methods; Disruptive technology and fugitive gas emissions
Automation Engineer; Wood Group
System Integrator; Cross Integrated Systems Group
Jose S. Vasquez, Jr.
Fire & Life Safety Engineer; Technip USA Inc.
This course focuses on climate analysis, appropriateness of cooling system selection, and combining cooling systems.
This course will help identify and reveal electrical hazards and identify the solutions to implementing and maintaining a safe work environment.
This course explains how maintaining power and communication systems through emergency power-generation systems is critical.
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by Control Engineering subscribers. Vote now (if qualified)!
The System Integrator Giants program lists the top 100 system integrators among companies listed in CFE Media's Global System Integrator Database.
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering and Plant Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners in three categories.
This eGuide illustrates solutions, applications and benefits of machine vision systems.
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
HMI effectiveness; Distributed I/O; Engineers' Choice Award finalists; System Integrator advice; Inside Machines
Women in engineering; Engineering Leaders Under 40; PID benefits and drawbacks; Ladder logic; Cloud computing
Robotic integration and cloud connections; SCADA and cybersecurity; Motor efficiency standards; Open- and closed-loop control; Augmented reality
Programmable logic controllers (PLCs) represent the logic (decision) part of the control loop of sense, decide, and actuate. As we know, PLCs aren’t the only option for making decisions in a control loop, but they are likely why you’re here.
This digital report explains how motion control advances and solutions can help with machine control, automated control on assembly lines, integration of robotics and automation, and machine safety.
This article collection contains several articles on how advancements in vision system designs, computing power, algorithms, optics, and communications are making machine vision more cost effective than ever before.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

Control room technology innovation; Practical approaches to corrosion protection; Pipeline regulator revises quality programs
Cloud, mobility, and remote operations; SCADA and contextual mobility; Custom UPS empowering a secure pipeline
Infrastructure for natural gas expansion; Artificial lift methods; Disruptive technology and fugitive gas emissions
Automation Engineer; Wood Group
System Integrator; Cross Integrated Systems Group
Jose S. Vasquez, Jr.
Fire & Life Safety Engineer; Technip USA Inc.
This course focuses on climate analysis, appropriateness of cooling system selection, and combining cooling systems.
This course will help identify and reveal electrical hazards and identify the solutions to implementing and maintaining a safe work environment.
This course explains how maintaining power and communication systems through emergency power-generation systems is critical.
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by Control Engineering subscribers. Vote now (if qualified)!
The System Integrator Giants program lists the top 100 system integrators among companies listed in CFE Media's Global System Integrator Database.
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering and Plant Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners in three categories.
This eGuide illustrates solutions, applications and benefits of machine vision systems.
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
HMI effectiveness; Distributed I/O; Engineers' Choice Award finalists; System Integrator advice; Inside Machines
Women in engineering; Engineering Leaders Under 40; PID benefits and drawbacks; Ladder logic; Cloud computing
Robotic integration and cloud connections; SCADA and cybersecurity; Motor efficiency standards; Open- and closed-loop control; Augmented reality
Programmable logic controllers (PLCs) represent the logic (decision) part of the control loop of sense, decide, and actuate. As we know, PLCs aren’t the only option for making decisions in a control loop, but they are likely why you’re here.
This digital report explains how motion control advances and solutions can help with machine control, automated control on assembly lines, integration of robotics and automation, and machine safety.
This article collection contains several articles on how advancements in vision system designs, computing power, algorithms, optics, and communications are making machine vision more cost effective than ever before.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

Control room technology innovation; Practical approaches to corrosion protection; Pipeline regulator revises quality programs
Cloud, mobility, and remote operations; SCADA and contextual mobility; Custom UPS empowering a secure pipeline
Infrastructure for natural gas expansion; Artificial lift methods; Disruptive technology and fugitive gas emissions
Automation Engineer; Wood Group
System Integrator; Cross Integrated Systems Group
Jose S. Vasquez, Jr.
Fire & Life Safety Engineer; Technip USA Inc.
This course focuses on climate analysis, appropriateness of cooling system selection, and combining cooling systems.
This course will help identify and reveal electrical hazards and identify the solutions to implementing and maintaining a safe work environment.
This course explains how maintaining power and communication systems through emergency power-generation systems is critical.
click me