Comparing mechanical and electronic variable speed drives

Variable speed was accomplished by simple, yet complex, variable speed mechanical drives long before ac inverters or variable frequency drives (VFDs), vector drives, dc brushless controls, or integrated inverter/motor drives were available.

08/01/1999


Variable speed was accomplished by simple, yet complex, variable speed mechanical drives long before ac inverters or variable frequency drives (VFDs), vector drives, dc brushless controls, or integrated inverter/motor drives were available. Once semiconductor modules became reliable, retrofits of mechanical variable speed con- trols steadily increased.

But questions have continued to linger. Why should I change? Why should I replace what works? Is electronic control really that much better?

Mechanical variable speed controls, such as variable speed sheaves (Fig. 1), enclosed variable speed drives, and belt-boxes, provided reliable speed control of various processes. Hand turning a wheel, electronically moving a motor base, and creating more tension on the belts are all used to change the ratio of the operating diameters of connected sheaves. Not a bad way of controlling speed, but not exactly the easiest or most efficient.

Mechanical variable speed drives, which have the motor operating at full speed, can increase or decrease speed, but cannot provide the energy savings and efficiencies of today's electronic controls. Mechanical drives are typically 70-80% efficient, while an ac inverter and motor combination can be 85-90% efficient in certain applications.

Why change?

Ease of operation is the basic reason for changing to VFD. The simplicity of the change makes the use of a VFD for variable speed an excellent long-term solution. No belts to change, no oil to add to the sheaves, and broader speed ranges are some advantages. Not bad for a box with a bunch of wires.

A VFD can be easily installed in conjunction with an existing motor starter or as a replacement. Panel space or NEMA enclosed models could present a limitation, but inverters can be mounted separately. VFDs have been used for years in new installations, and for many facilities that are moving to more electronic controls than mechanical, the change to all electrical is becoming a less painful process.

The time to replace mechanical variable speed drives is up to the individual user. Factors such as increased maintenance costs, need for increased productivity, or cost-effective replacement if a mechanical system is damaged must be considered. Since most of the VFD expense is in the initial installation, cost savings are achieved through zero maintenance and higher efficiencies of the electronic system.

How VFDs work

VFDs accomplish speed control by changing the current frequency from the control to the motor. They have the ability to control both current frequency and voltage to make the ac motor operate over a broad speed range. Typically, speeds range from 4:1 for variable torque loads, such as fans and pumps, up to 1000:1 for machine tools and material handling applications.

Synchronous speed of an induction motor is determined by the number of poles in the motor and the frequency applied to it.

Speed = 120 X Frequency/# of Poles

AC induction motor designs are based on the number of magnetic poles in the motor. The number of poles determines the base speed of the motor. For example, a 1750-rpm (1800-rpm synchronous) motor is based on a 4-pole design with 60-Hz applied to the motor. If the frequency applied to the motor is changed, the operating speed changes.

Unfortunately, it is not entirely that easy. AC motors are also designed based on the amount of torque/horsepower they need to develop. This torque can be controlled as long as the ratio between voltage and frequency is maintained.

For example, a 5-hp ac motor rated for 460 V at 60 Hz can be operated from a VFD over a motor manufacturer-specified speed range. If this motor is slowed to half speed (30 Hz, or 900-rpm synchronous), the voltage-to-frequency ratio (V/Hz) must be maintained. The inverter must be able to provide 230 V to the motor in order to produce full torque capacity.

As loads and applications change, the need for additional features within the VFD increases. With built-in overloads and digital keypads (Fig. 2), the VFD can provide approved motor protection to meet many electrical codes and monitoring functions to replace other equipment in the system. The single-source control vs multiple "black boxes" can also be very cost effective.

Pitfalls to avoid

As with any change in process control, being aware of limitations or disadvantages up front makes the retrofit much smoother. One of the mistakes made during retrofit of mechanical systems is to overlook the advantage in torque production due to the speed ratios of the mechanical components.

A 5-hp motor operating a 4:1 V-belt drive at 450 rpm produces 58.33 ft-lb of torque when drawing full current. Replacing the system with a VFD may require sizing the system for the torque required at low speed. In order to operate an ac motor at 450 rpm, a 20-hp VFD and motor rated at 1750 rpm may be required if full torque capacity is needed. A 20-hp system, when rated at 1750 rpm, develops 3 ft-lb of torque/hp or 60 ft-lb. An alternative would be a 15-hp motor rated at 1200 rpm that develops 4.5 ft-lb of torque/hp. Usually, the issue is speed, not torque, and the system must be sized for the application.

Other precautions that must be taken when retrofitting a system are motor cooling and bearing damage. Inverter-duty motors have become prevalent in today's marketplace. Although VFDs can operate noninverter-duty motors, the motors may not be designed to handle the speed ranges required for the application.

In ac motors, particularly those of a TEFC and TENV design, cooling capacity is directly related to either how fast the shaft turns the internal fan or the ability to radiate heat. Low speed, high torque operations can cause excessive heat and drastically cut the life span of the motor.

Bearing damage can also occur due to induced currents through the shaft of the motor and into the bearing housing. Many motors today are equipped with insulated bearings and are better able to survive these currents. The currents, created by the waveform from the inverter to the motor, can be reduced by placing filters in the line to the motor or through a choice of inverter design.

Integrated VFDs

Integration of VFD systems has increased with the advent of inverter/motor integrated controls (Fig. 3). These controls have the inverter mounted either on or in the motor housing with all associated wiring self-contained. This approach can also reduce the initial cost of a system by reducing external wiring and eliminating the need for extra panel space for the VFD.

These systems can be greatly simplified with simple connections for speed, start/stop controls, and limited external peripheral equipment. Replacement of the system is also simplified; removal and installation of one unit is all that is required. Integrated inverter/motor control systems operate in a variety of applications, with a primary focus on material handling, pumping, and HVAC.

VFDs and integrated inverter/motor drives are a solution for new installations requiring variable speed control. Mechanical variable speed has been used before, but with the advantages and cost effectiveness of electronic controls, they are becoming the replacement choice. Whether for retrofits or breakdown conditions, the electronic version has a short payback and simplicity of operation. -- Edited by Joseph L. Foszcz, Senior Editor, 630-320-7135, j.foszcz@cahners.com

Comparing variable speed drives

Electronic Mechanical

20:1 speed range 4:1 speed range

Maintenance required: Maintenance required:

Clean fan and heat sink Lubricate and adjust belts

Quick speed change Adjust pulley diameters

with keypad and check speed with

tachometer

More info

The author is available to answer questions on applying and converting to variable frequency drives. He can be reached at 717-264-7161 x4434.

Key concepts

Electronic speed controls are more efficient, accurate, and cost effective than mechanical types.

Variable frequency drives can work with existing motors, but the application should be checked out.

Inverter motors, suited for variable speed applications, must have proper cooling fans and bearing protection.





No comments
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by...
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners.
Control Engineering Leaders Under 40 identifies and gives recognition to young engineers who...
Learn more about methods used to ensure that the integration between the safety system and the process control...
Adding industrial toughness and reliability to Ethernet eGuide
Technological advances like multiple-in-multiple-out (MIMO) transmitting and receiving
Big plans for small nuclear reactors: Simpler, safer control designs; Smarter manufacturing; Industrial cloud; Mobile HMI; Controls convergence
Virtualization advice: 4 ways splitting servers can help manufacturing; Efficient motion controls; Fill the brain drain; Learn from the HART Plant of the Year
Two sides to process safety: Combining human and technical factors in your program; Preparing HMI graphics for migrations; Mechatronics and safety; Engineers' Choice Awards
The Ask Control Engineering blog covers all aspects of automation, including motors, drives, sensors, motion control, machine control, and embedded systems.
Join this ongoing discussion of machine guarding topics, including solutions assessments, regulatory compliance, gap analysis...
News and comments from Control Engineering process industries editor, Peter Welander.
IMS Research, recently acquired by IHS Inc., is a leading independent supplier of market research and consultancy to the global electronics industry.
This is a blog from the trenches – written by engineers who are implementing and upgrading control systems every day across every industry.
Anthony Baker is a fictitious aggregation of experts from Callisto Integration, providing manufacturing consulting and systems integration.
Integrator Guide

Integrator Guide

Search the online Automation Integrator Guide
 

Create New Listing

Visit the System Integrators page to view past winners of Control Engineering's System Integrator of the Year Award and learn how to enter the competition. You will also find more information on system integrators and Control System Integrators Association.

Case Study Database

Case Study Database

Get more exposure for your case study by uploading it to the Control Engineering case study database, where end-users can identify relevant solutions and explore what the experts are doing to effectively implement a variety of technology and productivity related projects.

These case studies provide examples of how knowledgeable solution providers have used technology, processes and people to create effective and successful implementations in real-world situations. Case studies can be completed by filling out a simple online form where you can outline the project title, abstract, and full story in 1500 words or less; upload photos, videos and a logo.

Click here to visit the Case Study Database and upload your case study.