Controller selection criteria

Selecting a controller for an industrial application can be increasingly difficult with all the options available. These 11 selection criteria can help when deciding among relays, timers, analog instruments, smart relays, programmable logic controllers (PLCs), and programmable automation controllers (PACs). See controller selection table.

05/27/2015


Idec SmartAxis series FT1A controllers are available in 12, 24, 40, 48, I/O CPUs, and 3.8-in. HMI+PLC 65K color TFT or STN monochrome touchscreen. Courtesy: IdecBasic choices and selection criteria follow to help in specifying a controller for an industrial application. Eleven criteria in the table can help when selecting a controller type from among relays, timers, analog instruments, smart relays, programmable logic controller (PLCs), and programmable automation controllers (PACs).

Relays, timers, and analog instruments: Despite the proliferation of inexpensive smart relays and micro PLCs, many thousands of control systems are built each year using these basic components. The big advantage of these systems is simplicity, as even the dullest technician can understand and troubleshoot them. No programming is required; thus there is no need for software licenses or PCs. When the number of relays and timers exceeds four, it's best to upgrade to a smart relay.

Smart relays: These have grown more capable over the years, blurring the line between them and micro PLCs. Smart relays can be programmed with PC-based software, but many can also be programmed from their front panel display. Ladder logic or function block is the language of choice, and analog capabilities range from slim to none. 

PLCs: These workhorses run the range from micros with about 32 built-in input/output (I/O) points to full-featured systems capable of handling thousands of I/O. PLCs are programmed with PC-based software, and any changes to the program require a PC. But, many parameters can be adjusted with a local operator interface, which is built-in with a combination of PLC and human machine interface (HMI) units, an emerging class of controllers combining a PLC with a graphical interface (Table 1). 

Table 1: Controller selection criteria

Characteristics

Relay/timer

Smart relay

PLC

PAC

Maximum I/O

10

20

Up to 2,000

Up to 100,000

Footprint

Largest

Smallest

Depends on I/O quantity

Depends on I/O quantity

Local expansion capability

n/a

n/a

Medium

High

Remote expansion capability

n/a

n/a

Medium

High

Programming languages

n/a

Ladder, some function blocks

Ladder and maybe other specialty function blocks

Multiple-Ladder, structure text, function block, etc.

Programming software cost

n/a

Free to low

Free to medium

Medium to High

Hardware cost

Lowest

Low

Medium

High

Program memory

n/a

Low

High

Very High

Ease of use

Easiest

Easy

Medium

Difficult

Flexibility

Very low

Low

High

High

Connectivity to other systems

Hard-wired only

One communication port and protocol

Multiple communication ports and protocols

Multiple communication ports and protocols

PACs: Lines are once again blurred, but this time between high-end PLCs and PACs. But PACs add more capabilities than PLCs, particularly for control of very complex systems. PACs can handle advanced motion control, incorporate vision systems, and perform advanced control of analog loops—a set of tasks that might unduly burden a PLC.

Distributed control systems (DCS) were intentionally left out of this discussion because most are now PAC-based. While exceptions abound, these criteria are a good starting point for controller selection (Table 1). Table 2 shows the current and anticipated future state of these markets.

Table 2: This table shows the current and anticipated future state of these markets, according to IHS. Courtesy: Idec

- Don Pham is product manager at Idec; edited by Mark T. Hoske, content manager, CFE Media, Control Engineering, mhoske@cfemedia.com.

Key concepts

  • Criteria can help when selecting among relays, smart relays, PLCs, and PACs.
  • Considerations include I/O needs, expansion, programming, and connectivity, among others.

Consider this

Can these 11 criteria help with the selection of your next controller? 

ONLINE extra

www.idec.com 

Control Engineering articles linked below look at PLCs versus PACs, PCs versus PLCs, the future of the PLC, and managing the DCS upgrade. 



No comments
The Engineers' Choice Awards highlight some of the best new control, instrumentation and automation products as chosen by...
The System Integrator Giants program lists the top 100 system integrators among companies listed in CFE Media's Global System Integrator Database.
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering and Plant Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners in three categories.
This eGuide illustrates solutions, applications and benefits of machine vision systems.
Learn how to increase device reliability in harsh environments and decrease unplanned system downtime.
This eGuide contains a series of articles and videos that considers theoretical and practical; immediate needs and a look into the future.
Additive manufacturing benefits; HMI and sensor tips; System integrator advice; Innovations from the industry
Robotic safety, collaboration, standards; DCS migration tips; IT/OT convergence; 2017 Control Engineering Salary and Career Survey
Integrated mobility; Artificial intelligence; Predictive motion control; Sensors and control system inputs; Asset Management; Cybersecurity
Featured articles highlight technologies that enable the Industrial Internet of Things, IIoT-related products and strategies to get data more easily to the user.
This article collection contains several articles on how automation and controls are helping human-machine interface (HMI) hardware and software advance.
This digital report will explore several aspects of how IIoT will transform manufacturing in the coming years.

Find and connect with the most suitable service provider for your unique application. Start searching the Global System Integrator Database Now!

Infrastructure for natural gas expansion; Artificial lift methods; Disruptive technology and fugitive gas emissions
Mobility as the means to offshore innovation; Preventing another Deepwater Horizon; ROVs as subsea robots; SCADA and the radio spectrum
Future of oil and gas projects; Reservoir models; The importance of SCADA to oil and gas
Automation Engineer; Wood Group
System Integrator; Cross Integrated Systems Group
Jose S. Vasquez, Jr.
Fire & Life Safety Engineer; Technip USA Inc.
This course focuses on climate analysis, appropriateness of cooling system selection, and combining cooling systems.
This course will help identify and reveal electrical hazards and identify the solutions to implementing and maintaining a safe work environment.
This course explains how maintaining power and communication systems through emergency power-generation systems is critical.
click me